← Grammar Lab

Why Is “What to Do” Confusing to Non-Indian Speakers?

3 min read · Indian English · Spoken English

The short answer

“What to do” is a fixed resignation phrase Indian English speakers attach to the end of almost any statement about an unwanted situation — a direct translation of the Hindi “kya karen.” It sounds like an unanswered question, but no answer is expected. Native English speakers use “oh well” or “it can’t be helped” for the same idea.

Confusing vs. Natural

Indian English

The train was late, what to do.

Natural English

The train was late — there was nothing I could do about it.

Indian English

He doesn't listen, what to do.

Natural English

He just doesn't listen. Oh well.

Indian English

Prices have gone up, what to do.

Natural English

Prices have gone up — it can't be helped.

Indian English

I have to attend, what to do.

Natural English

I have to attend; there's no way around it.

Why Do People Say It?

In Hindi, “kya karen” is a common idiom of resignation — a way of saying “nothing can be done about this” without literally asking for a solution. It plays the same role as English fillers like “oh well” or “such is life.” Because it is phrased as a question in Hindi, speakers translate it word-for-word into English as “what to do,” carrying over the grammatical shape but not the idiomatic meaning.

To a listener unfamiliar with this habit, the phrase can sound like a genuine, unanswered question — leaving them unsure whether they are expected to respond.

Exam tip

For IELTS Speaking and any formal register, drop the tag “what to do” entirely, or replace it with a proper closing statement: “there’s nothing I can do about it,” “it can’t be helped,” or simply end the sentence without a resignation tag at all.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is 'what to do' grammatically wrong?+

Not exactly. As a genuine question ('What am I to do?'), it is fine. The confusing part is the Indian English habit of tacking 'what to do' onto the end of almost any statement about an unwanted situation, with no real question intended — it functions as a fixed expression of resignation, not a request for advice.

Why do Indians say 'what to do'?+

It is a direct translation of the Hindi phrase 'kya karen' (literally 'what to do'), which functions in Hindi as an idiom of resignation — the same role English speakers give to 'oh well' or 'such is life'. Speakers carry the exact Hindi phrase into English without converting it to an English idiom.

What should I say instead of 'what to do' in formal English?+

Use 'there's nothing I/we can do about it', 'it can't be helped', or, in casual speech, 'oh well'. These carry the same resignation without sounding like an unanswered question to a listener unfamiliar with the Indian usage.

Read Next